Tuesday, January 26, 2010
Israel Poised to Challenge a U.N. Report on Gaza
7:06 AM
No comments
January 24, 2010
By ETHAN BRONNER
TEL AVIV — The Israeli military is completing a rebuttal to a United Nations report accusing it of grave violations of international and humanitarian law in its Gazainvasion a year ago. Its central aim is to dispel the report’s harsh conclusion — that the death of noncombatants and destruction of civilian infrastructure were part of an official plan to terrorize the Palestinian population.
The United Nations report, by a committee led by Richard Goldstone, an esteemed South African judge, was published in late September and called on Israel to carry out an independent investigation of its conduct of the three-week war.
Israel, which had refused to cooperate with the investigation, at first dismissed the report as unworthy of attention. But the government quickly found that the world took it quite seriously and found itself accused of premeditated war crimes. It now considers fighting that charge a priority.
“We face three major strategic challenges,” Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said recently. “The Iranian nuclear program, rockets aimed at our civilians and Goldstone.”
The rebuttal will be given to United Nations officials in the coming weeks and its contents will remain under wraps until then. But officers involved in writing the report gave some details.
One concerned the destruction of Gaza’s sole flour mill. The Goldstone report asserts that the Bader flour mill “was hit by an airstrike, possibly by an F-16.” The Israeli investigators say they have photographic proof that this is false, that the mill was accidentally hit by artillery in the course of a firefight with Hamas militiamen.
The dispute is significant since the United Nations report asserts that “the destruction of the mill was carried out for the purpose of denying sustenance to the civilian population,” an explicit war crime.
A second finding concerned the destruction of a wastewater plant, leading to an enormous outflow of raw sewage. The Goldstone report contended that it was hit by a powerful Israeli missile in a strike that was “deliberate and premeditated.” The Israelis say they had nothing to do with that plant’s collapse and suggest that it may have been the result of Hamas explosives.
The two cases, along with the destruction of chicken coops, water wells, a cement plant and some 4,000 homes, are crucial building blocks in the Goldstone case that Israel set out to eliminate infrastructure so as to cause intense civilian suffering.
The report stated that “the destruction of food supply installations, water sanitation systems, concrete factories and residential houses was the result of a deliberate and systematic policy by the Israeli armed forces.” It added that Israel waged “a deliberately disproportionate attack designed to punish, humiliate and terrorize a civilian population, radically diminish its local economic capacity both to work and to provide for itself, and to force upon it an ever increasing sense of dependency and vulnerability.”
Maj. Gen. Avichai Mandelblit, the Israeli military advocate general, said in an interview that those assertions went beyond anything of which others had accused Israel.
“I have read every report, from Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, the Arab League,” he said at his desk in the military’s Tel Aviv headquarters. “We ourselves set up investigations into 140 complaints. It is when you read these other reports and complaints that you realize how truly vicious the Goldstone report is. He made it look like we set out to go after the economic infrastructure and civilians, that it was intentional. It’s a vicious lie.”
Another senior military official who spoke on the condition of anonymity following regular military practice, said that neither the military command structure nor the government wanted to invade Gaza in December 2008, but felt that the continual rocket attacks by Hamas on Israeli civilians forced their hand. The war, he said, followed the least aggressive of three contemplated routes — conquer Gaza and occupy it again as was done in the West Bank in 2002, retake Hamas’s weapons supply routes and hold them to dry out the organization’s arsenal, or attack the Hamas military and state infrastructure and leave. It was the third that occurred.
That invasion killed some 1,400 Palestinians and destroyed a great deal of property, including buildings like the parliament’s offices that have no military function. There were accusations of inappropriate weapons use. All that led many human rights advocates, both foreign and Israeli, to accuse Israel of violating international norms.
So in November, Brig. Gen. Yuval Halamish, a former intelligence commander, led an investigation that involved scores of interviews of Israeli soldiers and Palestinian witnesses as well as reviewing military videotape and photographs. He submitted his findings to General Mandelblit, who is independent of the command structure but who wears a uniform, offered legal advice on targets before the operation and is widely seen as an insider.
The military investigation is expected to argue that while errors were made, Israel is not guilty of any serious crimes. It will argue that the rules of war need to be adapted to the kind of asymmetric warfare Israel increasingly faces: fighting a popular militia that intentionally mixes with the civilian population.
Mr. Netanyahu and his government have not decided whether to submit the findings to independent scrutiny, as the Goldstone report specifies. They may do so in a partial way — by asking a group of nonmilitary Israeli jurists to examine the rebuttal but without power to recall witnesses, an approach favored by the military and those close to it.
Others say there must be an independent, nonmilitary investigation.
“Israel owes it to its own citizens and soldiers, as well as to the victims, to carry out an independent investigation,” said Moshe Halbertal, a professor of Jewish philosophy at Hebrew University and a co-author of the military’s code of ethics.
Mr. Halbertal said that he was concerned about persistent reports during the Gaza operation that commanders had a “no risk” policy for their soldiers, which led to the unnecessary destruction of property and the shooting of civilians who were feared dangerous.
This is also the view of the organization Breaking the Silence, a group of military reservists who have given testimony about receiving orders in the war to shoot or destroy in ways that violated ethical standards and the military’s own code.
General Halamish said in an interview that the army chose not to attack many leaders of Hamas because they lived among children and the elderly. He added that during the operation, Israel withheld fire for three hours a day so food and other aid supplies could be brought into Gaza. During those hours, he said, a quarter of the shooting from Hamas took place. Hamas also ambushed the civilian supply trucks.
While many here think that the Goldstone report failed to expose of the practices of Hamas, they are more concerned about their own army’s conduct. Still, virtually no one in Israel, including the leaders of Breaking the Silence and the human rights group B’Tselem, thinks that the Goldstone accusation of an assault on civilians is correct.
“I do not accept the Goldstone conclusion of a systematic attack on civilian infrastructure,” said Yael Stein, research director of B’Tselem. “It is not convincing. But every incident and every policy has to be checked by an independent body because the military cannot check itself. They need to explain why so many people were killed.”
About Anonymous
Islamic Societies Review Editors
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Most popular articles
-
قالت هيومن رايتس ووتش اليوم إن جماعات معارضة مسلحة تقاتل في سوريا تستخدم أطفالاً في القتال وفي أغراض عسكرية أخرى. تبينت لهيومن رايتس و...
-
Reasoned Comments and Reviews Books: Does the sharia deserve its bad reputation, asks S... : Heaven on Earth: a Journey Through Sharia Law ,...
-
محمد حيان السمان* يبدو أن القانونَ الأبديّ المتعلق بتعبيرات ما قبل الدولة الدستورية, والقائل بحتمية التعسّف في استخدام السلطة حالَ ا...
-
Editors' Comment: Saudi Arabians rulers just spent nearly $500 trillions on weapons. When the Saudi rulers go on vacation, they take an...
-
تواصلت المواجهات المسلحة العنيفة والدموية في العديد من المدن السورية, واستمرت عمليات الاغتيال والاختطاف والاختفاء القسري والاعتقال ا...
-
أحمد رضي أثناء تشييع جواد الحاوي أمس في قرية سترة جنوب المنامة (محمد الشيخ ــ أ ف ب) لا يزال النظام البحريني يرفض السماح للمقرّر الخ...
-
The Bahrain Center for Human Rights expresses grave concern over the detention and sentencing of 16 Bahraini citizens to 15 years imp...
-
مهتاد لـ"الرأي": وزارة العدل تأخرت في فتح الحوار مع معتقلي السلفية الجهادية ...
-
قالت منظمة العفو الدولية يوم الثلاثاء إن الأساليب التي استخدمتها القوات العراقية والتحالف العسكري بقيادة الولايات المتحدة الذي يدعمها في ...
-
جهش المفوض العام لوكالة غوث وتشغيل اللاجئين الفلسطينيين (الاونروا) بيير كرينبول بالبكاء، خلال مقابلة مع قناة «الجزيرة» أمس، من هول المجز...
Karama Videos
Frequently Used Labels and Topics
2011 War
Abuse of Power
Aggression
All
Apartheid
Bahrain
Bangladesh
Capitalism and Exploitation
child labor
children rights
Civil Rights
Colonialism
Conflict
Crimes Against Humanity
Death Penalty
Denmark
Dissent
Europe
Executions
Exploitation
Family Separation
Fiqh
freedom of conscience
Genocide
Guantanamo
human rights
Human Rights in Europe
HUQUQ
ICC
immigration
Incarceration and Rights
Indigenous
International Law
International Relations
Inuit
Journalism
Labor
Media Bias
migration
Muslim Ban
Muslims in Europe
Muslims in France
Nakba
Nationalism
Palestine
PoliceBrutality
Politics
Prison systems and human rights
Racism
religion and conflict
Remediation
Reparations
Rights
Rights in Western Societies
Rohingya Genocide
sanctions
Saudi Arabia
Sectarianism
Sexual Exploitation
Sham Trials
Sharia
Slavery
Supremacy
Syria
Terrorism
Torture
uk
UN
Universal Rights
USA
War and Peace
War Crimes
War On Iraq
War On Terror
WMDs
woman rights
Yemen
ألتكفير
التحريض على الكراهية
السجن التعسفي
جرائم الحرب
حقوق
كرامة
Search for old news
Find Articles by year, month hierarchy
-
►
2023
(23)
- ► September 2023 (6)
- ► August 2023 (2)
- ► April 2023 (2)
- ► February 2023 (7)
- ► January 2023 (1)
-
►
2022
(5)
- ► December 2022 (1)
- ► November 2022 (1)
- ► October 2022 (3)
-
►
2018
(1)
- ► September 2018 (1)
-
►
2017
(19)
- ► September 2017 (4)
- ► August 2017 (2)
- ► March 2017 (1)
- ► February 2017 (2)
- ► January 2017 (2)
-
►
2014
(8)
- ► December 2014 (1)
- ► August 2014 (2)
- ► March 2014 (2)
- ► January 2014 (1)
-
►
2013
(23)
- ► April 2013 (3)
- ► March 2013 (3)
- ► February 2013 (6)
- ► January 2013 (1)
-
►
2012
(37)
- ► December 2012 (4)
- ► November 2012 (7)
- ► October 2012 (4)
- ► September 2012 (1)
- ► August 2012 (3)
- ► April 2012 (4)
- ► March 2012 (2)
- ► February 2012 (9)
- ► January 2012 (1)
-
►
2011
(28)
- ► December 2011 (2)
- ► October 2011 (1)
- ► September 2011 (3)
- ► August 2011 (5)
- ► April 2011 (5)
- ► March 2011 (5)
- ► February 2011 (3)
- ► January 2011 (2)
-
▼
2010
(50)
- ► December 2010 (4)
- ► November 2010 (4)
- ► October 2010 (9)
- ► September 2010 (6)
- ► August 2010 (1)
- ► April 2010 (10)
- ► March 2010 (5)
- ► February 2010 (1)
-
►
2009
(60)
- ► December 2009 (5)
- ► November 2009 (19)
- ► October 2009 (6)
- ► September 2009 (6)
- ► August 2009 (1)
- ► March 2009 (6)
- ► February 2009 (1)
- ► January 2009 (12)
-
►
2008
(27)
- ► December 2008 (6)
- ► October 2008 (4)
- ► September 2008 (1)
- ► April 2008 (4)
- ► March 2008 (2)
- ► February 2008 (3)
- ► January 2008 (3)
-
►
2007
(77)
- ► December 2007 (3)
- ► November 2007 (3)
- ► October 2007 (1)
- ► September 2007 (8)
- ► August 2007 (14)
- ► April 2007 (3)
Contact Us
_______________________________________________
Copyright © KARAMA. All rights reserved.
Copyright © KARAMA. All rights reserved.
Read this in your preferred language
Search
Trending now
Most Popular Articles
-
قالت هيومن رايتس ووتش اليوم إن جماعات معارضة مسلحة تقاتل في سوريا تستخدم أطفالاً في القتال وفي أغراض عسكرية أخرى. تبينت لهيومن رايتس و...
-
Reasoned Comments and Reviews Books: Does the sharia deserve its bad reputation, asks S... : Heaven on Earth: a Journey Through Sharia Law ,...
-
محمد حيان السمان* يبدو أن القانونَ الأبديّ المتعلق بتعبيرات ما قبل الدولة الدستورية, والقائل بحتمية التعسّف في استخدام السلطة حالَ ا...
-
Editors' Comment: Saudi Arabians rulers just spent nearly $500 trillions on weapons. When the Saudi rulers go on vacation, they take an...
-
تواصلت المواجهات المسلحة العنيفة والدموية في العديد من المدن السورية, واستمرت عمليات الاغتيال والاختطاف والاختفاء القسري والاعتقال ا...
-
أحمد رضي أثناء تشييع جواد الحاوي أمس في قرية سترة جنوب المنامة (محمد الشيخ ــ أ ف ب) لا يزال النظام البحريني يرفض السماح للمقرّر الخ...
-
The Bahrain Center for Human Rights expresses grave concern over the detention and sentencing of 16 Bahraini citizens to 15 years imp...
-
مهتاد لـ"الرأي": وزارة العدل تأخرت في فتح الحوار مع معتقلي السلفية الجهادية ...
-
قالت منظمة العفو الدولية يوم الثلاثاء إن الأساليب التي استخدمتها القوات العراقية والتحالف العسكري بقيادة الولايات المتحدة الذي يدعمها في ...
-
جهش المفوض العام لوكالة غوث وتشغيل اللاجئين الفلسطينيين (الاونروا) بيير كرينبول بالبكاء، خلال مقابلة مع قناة «الجزيرة» أمس، من هول المجز...
Most read in the last 90 days...
-
On February 1, 2023, Amnesty said that "Israeli authorities must dismantle the system of apartheid which is causing so much suffering a...
-
A UK court ruling that the government is entitled to continue authorizing arms supplies to Saudi Arabia is a potentially deadly setback to ...
-
Haaretz newspaper revealed that during the Nakba, Ben-Gurion ordered that Palestinian wells be poisoned to prevent people from return. Wells...
-
Apparently he was tortured for fun only, not for interrogation purpose. Victim was a mentally challenged civilian . Abducted with unc...
-
Editors' Comment: Saudi Arabians rulers just spent nearly $500 trillions on weapons. When the Saudi rulers go on vacation, they take an...
-
Denmark and Greenland have formally agreed to launch a two-year investigation into historic birth control practices carried out for many ye...
-
محمد حيان السمان* يبدو أن القانونَ الأبديّ المتعلق بتعبيرات ما قبل الدولة الدستورية, والقائل بحتمية التعسّف في استخدام السلطة حالَ ا...
-
The British " Declassified " website talked about the role of the British media in promoting the lies of the British government ...
-
قالت هيومن رايتس ووتش اليوم إن جماعات معارضة مسلحة تقاتل في سوريا تستخدم أطفالاً في القتال وفي أغراض عسكرية أخرى. تبينت لهيومن رايتس و...
-
The war in Ukraine cannot be seen just as the war in Ukraine; precedent setting has consequences. The reluctance in Muslim majority countrie...
Seen a relevant news story you would to share or review for KARAMA? Send it to us.
In the News Now
News stories from around the world (third-party content)
No comments:
Write comments